Sneaky plan for mandatory ID cards in the works
November 16, 2008 ·
by David Leppard
Ministers have been accused of trying to introduce compulsory identity cards through the back door, despite promises that people will not have to carry them.
Lawyers at Liberty, the civil liberties group, say that little noticed clauses in the draft immigration and citizenship bill introduce new powers to make people produce identity documents or face arrest. The bill is expected to be in the Queen’s speech next month.
At issue is a clause in the bill which says that anyone who is to be examined by an immigration officer “must produce a valid identity document if required to do so”. Failure to produce an identity card or otherwise prove identity will become a criminal offence. At present, producing a passport counts as proof of identity.
It had been thought the clauses applied only to people entering the UK at ports.
But Liberty says a separate clause in the bill extends powers of examination to new categories of people. They include anyone in the UK — whether a British citizen or not — who has ever left the country.
Isabella Sankey, Liberty’s policy officer, said: “Immigration law is being used as a cloak to introduce measures that would effectively compel us all to carry ID cards. Under these paranoid proposals if you have ever set foot outside the UK you could be required, at any time, to prove your identity and nationality.”
The Home Office disputed Liberty’s reading of the bill. A spokesman said: “The bill does not contain legislation that will require UK citizens to be issued with compulsory ID cards. It clearly states that valid identity documents must be produced on request to maintain effective immigration control.”
Launch of the ID cards scheme begins next week when marriage visa holders and non-European Union students will be the first recipients.
Airside workers at some airports will then be issued with cards — a move opposed by pilots’ unions and related groups.
The cards were proposed after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in America. Opponents say they are expensive, unnecessary and infringe on human rights.
Cards will carry a picture and security chip containing biometric data.
Categories: · Police State Dictatorship
UK “secure” child database accessible by one million “officials”
November 14, 2008 ·
UK’s ’secure’ child protection database will be open to one million
By Chris Williams and John Ozimek
More than three times as many officials will be able to access sensitive information on every child in England and Wales held in the forthcoming ContactPoint database than estimates circulated by the government suggest, research by The Register has found.
ContactPoint is now scheduled to launch in January. It will store and share data including every child’s name, home address and school, and information about their legal guardians. The government has argued it could help prevent cases similar to the horrific death of Baby P, whose tormentors were convicted at the Old Bailey yesterday.
Publicly available staffing figures from education authorities, the NHS, social services and other organisations show that more than one million government employees will have access to ContactPoint.
The Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) has told parliament that only 330,000 will use the delayed centralised data sharing system.
DCSF ministers Lord Adonis and Kevin Brennan have told both houses of parliament “the number of users is estimated to be around 330,000″.
Use versus access
The lesser figure has been repeatedly highlighted by ContactPoint’s critics as reason to fear it will be open to abuse. News that the true number of users could top a million will provide them with more ammunition to attack the government’s security claims. Although ministers have emphasised the numbers who will “use” ContactPoint rather than be able to access the database, it’s the latter that is seen as most important by campaigners, who are concerned the database will be easily trawled by abusive former partners seeking a reunion, for example.
At time of publications DCSF had not respond to requests for comment on the much wider access to ContactPoint our research reveals.
Both the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats have pledged to scrap ContactPoint.
Maria Miller, the Tories’ shadow minister for children, schools and families told The Register: “An independent review by Deloitte in February said that urgent changes needed to be made to ContactPoint before the government could implement it. Now more problems are emerging with ContactPoint and still the government thinks it is acceptable to introduce it.
“They have grossly underestimated the number of people who will have access to children’s data and now more children will be put at risk. ContactPoint should be scrapped.”
The Conservatives want to replace ContactPoint with a smaller system that will only hold data on children deemed at risk. Officials wrote to councils in October arguing against the alternative scheme. DCSF later apologised for the breach of civil service political impartiality rules.
The total number of government employees who will have access to ContactPoint among only GPs and the police is more than 323,000, official figures show.
Hat tip Aftermathnews
Centurean2\'s Weblog 